The #1 career mistake CSMs make


Hey Reader,


Let me tell you a quick story.


Back in the early years of my CS career, I thought I was doing everything right – I hit my goals, I supported my team, I made customers happy, I kept renewals solid… in short, I thought I was killing it. 😀


So when a promotion opportunity came up, I thought I was the obvious choice.


But I didn’t get it.


Someone else did – a teammate I honestly thought I was outperforming.


And that moment stuck with me. Not because I was jealous (okay, yea I was), but because I couldn’t make sense of it. I thought being good at your job was how you moved up.


Turns out… I was wrong. 🙃


Here’s the truth I had to learn the hard way:


👉 Being good at your job isn’t enough to get promoted.


And yet, I see so many amazing CSMs fall into the same trap:


They work overtime, go above and beyond for customers, hit every metric, burn themselves out trying to be the “perfect” CSM…


And still, they get passed over for growth opportunities, again and again.


That was me, too, until I realized something that completely changed my career:


👉 It’s not about being the best CSM – it’s about being seen as the most strategic one.


The teammate who gets promoted isn’t always the one with the best QBRs or the highest NPS.


It’s the one who knows how to make their impact visible. The one who understands what leadership actually cares about and delivers on that, not just customer results.


Once I learned how to do that? That’s when everything changed in my career.


I went from getting passed over to getting promoted like clockwork – every year, without fail.


Not because I was working longer hours (I wasn’t).


Not because I suddenly became the most technical person on the team (heck no 😅).


But because I started thinking and communicating like the leaders I was reporting to.


And by the time I left my last CS role to start coaching full-time, I was earning over $215K as an individual contributor. 🔥

So if you’re in that same place right now, wondering why your hard work isn’t getting noticed, I want you to hear this:


The problem is not in your skills or your dedication – you just haven’t been taught how to strategically move the needle in your CS career.


So, my advice would be to dedicate the next few months to building skills like:


✔️ Making your impact visible to decision-makers


✔️ Advocating for yourself without sounding braggy


✔️ Translating your work into clear ROI that leadership can act on


Those are some of the things I now teach my 1:1 coaching clients because no one taught us this stuff when we started our Customer Success careers.


And it’s important to remember: you don’t have to change who you are – you just have to learn how to tell your story in a way that gets you promoted.


Because you deserve a CS role that recognizes your value, and you deserve to grow confidently in your career, not stay stuck doing great work that nobody sees.


If this hit home for you, I’d love to hear what your biggest challenge is right now when it comes to career growth. Just hit reply to this email – I read every message.


To your success,


Carly

Carly Agar Training

Read more from Carly Agar Training

Hey Reader, One of the hardest things to watch as a career coach is amazing people getting knocked down in their job search because they can’t figure out how to adapt to this crazy new job market. Because here’s the truth: these days, you can be the perfect match on paper for a role… and still not get anywhere. 😐 That was the situation A.P. was in when she first reached out. She came to us after months of applying, with only two interviews under her belt. She kept saying, “But my background...

Hey Reader, We can all agree that the job market has been…chaotic these past couple of years, right? The wildest thing? Every job posting seems to get hundreds, if not thousands, of applicants. Sure, half of them are “spray and pray” applications sent to every open job on the internet, but still, the numbers can be intimidating. So, who are the people who actually land these roles? 🤔 Well, my team and I speak directly with CS hiring managers on a regular basis, and they all say that the...

Hey Reader, Have you noticed that we humans are obsessed with growth – in our lives, in our careers, in our bank accounts? But lately I’ve been wondering… what if growth doesn’t always mean more? What if it just means different? I’ve been wrestling with this idea my whole life. People have always challenged some of my choices and guilt-tripped me in the name of growth. Like the time I left a big enterprise company to join a small startup. “Isn’t that a step back?” they asked. Honestly? It was...